I generally find westerns boring, not because of the setting but because they invariably are stupid, macho, and corny. I’ve found a few exceptions, most notably ‘Unforgiven’, so I thought I’d give this remake a shot, as it had the advantage of not featuring John Wayne, at least.
It’s not stupid, macho, or corny…but it is boring.
The problem is that the believable characters are unlikeable and the likeable characters are unbelievable. Jeff Bridges conveys about as much charm as Billy Bob Thornton in ‘Sling Blade’, but his character’s excuse (stupidity/alcoholism) isn’t near as valid as Thornton’s character (severe mental illness). And Thornton’s character at least has quirks…and interesting dialogue.
Vastly overrated.
Grade: D
Hmmm, I would have to disagree on the rating. I liked this film, but it’s mostly because of the young girl, who is the main character. I didn’t think she would end up alone, though. Not a very happy ending. I give it a C.