Kirk and a few others beam up into an alternate universe and meet Evil Spock. And evil others; but Spock is the key, like he usually is.
Moments of stupidity, but mostly quite interesting.
Highlights:
the premise
Spock/Evil Spock
general mood
Kirk/Evil Spock interaction
Kirk’s speech – truly moving, really
Lowlights:
Kirk’s amazing cheezy revelation/weak cheezy reactions to it
weak Evil supporting reactions on the Good Enterprise
Kirk’s “romance”
fitting in Marlena
sad DRAMATIC combat
sad DRAMATIC Uhura/music
Spockism: “I do not threaten, Captain. I merely state facts.”