Anna Dalton – She Is Violinist Hear Her Emote (Composition Two, Final Draft)

This is the last song Anna wrote before her husband’s death…he wanted something upbeat after all her sad songs, so she composed this for, and about, him. It is her most special composition.

pose shifts the violin ever-so-slightly against her left shoulder, cradling it now as a newborn; something treasured, precious, delicate. Her head lowers to the point where it actually is touching the base of the instrument, making them, for the moment, joined. As her eyes begin to close, she exhales once, softly but faintly audible. Eyes closed completely, her right arm brings the bow to just above the top string of the violin.

pose draws the bow very slowly down, and a somewhat melancholy sound begins to coalesce; not truly depressing, but definitely on the sad side of the musical spectrum. Judging by the way the music emerges from the violin it seems almost as if she is playing intentionally in slow motion; the sounds and notes seem more suited for a faster pace, but are slowed – and quite probably saddened – intentionally, as if to accentuate their meaning, each one a special entity unto itself.

pose has her eyes closed, and her focus is absolute as the melancholy notes continue to emerge; rather than simply melting into the music she seems to submerge herself in it, to play with a loving, tender reverence. The veil she wears seems to heighten this effect, as if she has almost disappeared into what has been created and is being created. The notes bend, creak at times; but these are minor flaws, and the emotion and power of them are not lessened by the woman’s lack of mastery.

pose continues to play, slowly; her pace seems unshakable, an absolute focus, a certainty. The notes continue to bend and emerge sadly-tinged, bow moving up and down the strings at different varieties of slow, slower, slowest, creating different varieties of twisted, faintly tortured musings. They are seamless in that her hand never stops moving, but the motion is uneven, plying different noises from different places; reluctantly pulled out, perhaps, before the bow moves on to the next.

pose pauses – for the tiniest fraction of a moment – on certain notes; these seem to be fairly regular but not perfectly spaced, and at these points the sadness swells even more, pained notes declaring their esteemed positions at the heights of her bow’s movements and the song’s importance. The cracks seem to emerge the most here, but it seems almost as if that is intentional, as if she is pushing the notes as far as they will go, bending them until they creak in nearly breaking.

pose seems to alter and repeat this process then, the same method but with slightly alternately-tinged notes, slightly altered high points, slight variations…all the while, there are cracks in the smoothness of the playing, but they seem to be completely ignored and, in fact, the bow seems to linger in special attention on some of them. Finally coming to the end of the refrain, she slides the bow, now very gently, down the length of the instrument, pulling a few last sad notes from the strings.

pose slides the bow up instantly upon the last note fading and disappearing; her movements are as exaggeratedly fast as the previous ones were slow, though now it seems right, proper, completely true, as if the song had simply been waiting to come alive. The results are no longer sad: tiny pauses, only, separating proud, confident music; as majestic as the highest mountaintop, the most beautiful rainbow. The peaks of her playing, now, are almost exhilarating in their sweep and power, and she plays with utter and complete confidence, in tune with such music.

pose continues to play, bow moving at a furious pace as it proudly and defiantly elicits gorgeous swaths of occasionally flawed beauty; fairly regularly – but inexactly – placed pinnacles, each as surprising in its emergence as it is majestic. They seem to be never-ending; their energy appears able to last a lifetime. Her appearance doesn’t change except for the speed of her playing; she plays with virtually the same near-stillness of body, and the same expression, as she had previously.

pose seems tireless as the bow moves with remarkable speed, the music seeming alive and vibrant, unquenchable. It seems to slow, then, just slightly, as the volume drops just as slightly; melody not quite as powerful, but seeming satisfied to be that way, as if it has screamed out in defiance and is now content to simply reinforce such defiance and allow it to echo repeatedly. It slows, again; the bow gradually taming the relentless cries of defiant, undeniable life.

pose finally brings the song to a pause, suddenly, bow actually stopping for just a moment, allowing one last content, more subdued note to be drawn out fully and extended before moving down in a final reprise of the power and beauty of the highest notes, rephrasing their scream and focusing it, one last time, to greatest effect and at greatest volume. It seems to dare to be repudiated, declaring its unwillingness to die. She then stops, suddenly, lifting the bow from the violin as the last note fades away as quickly as it came. She is stark silent for a moment, unmoving, and then lowers both the bow and her head slightly.

Anna Dalton – She Is Violinist Hear Her Emote (Composition One, Final Draft)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qc6e8NOswOg

This composition is typical of most of Anna’s work: sad, somber, mournful. Most of her pieces are slow, so the fast motions here are somewhat unusual, but they do exist in some other pieces. As with all her compositions, this was not “written” in the actual sense of notes. It was played, by ear, over and over, until she felt it sounded as it should. She took notes (as she always does), but these consisted of general ideas and vague indications of tone shift, “louder”, “softer”, etc…not actual musical notes. And, like all of her compositions, it is always open to changes she feels…it is “alive”, like her husband.

pose shifts the violin ever-so-slightly, cradling it now as a newborn; something treasured, precious, delicate. Her head lowers to just above it as her eyes begin to close. She exhales once, softly but faintly audible, as her eyes shut fully, her right arm bringing the bow to just above the top string of the instrument. She seems to virtually melt into the violin as the string is touched by the bow, eyes clenching slightly just as sound emerges from her delicately-held instrument. It is faint, at first; as something beginning to grow from the smallest of seeds, breaking from nothingness into reality. The sound, quiet as it is, is decidedly mournful: a sad, longing, hopeless cry…destined to suffer for all eternity.

pose holds her wrist steady; it does not move except as it is drawn by her arm, as if the bow and arm were the only things allowed this luxury, two objects coming together to produce a whole. She glides the bow very, very slowly down from the top string, the quiet cry becoming louder; hopeless, despairing, opening up its sorrow to the world. That one note is sustained as the length of the bow moves down, her hand almost touching the mournful string as its call seems to reach its highest point; still not loud, but having risen steadily on the bow’s slow journey downward.

pose moves her head – and the violin – the slightest bit then, pulling the bow back up much more quickly than it had gone down. This slightly faster pace elicits three distinct notes, played so close together that they almost meld into one, their sounds similar to each other but quite different from the mournful downward note; while still sad, the music which emerges is at the same time defiant and strong, attempting to soothe the pain of the original note, to cradle it in empathetic warmth.

pose seems completely a part of the music, now…as if perhaps it is speaking to her, as well as responding to itself. There is a split-second pause as the bow reaches back to the top of the violin before she gently lowers it down again, instrument crying out just a bit louder, sadness not comforted, despair not soothed. The note is exactly the same as the first in tone, except for the faint echo of the first soothing reply, even as the strings begin to cry once more. The answer comes again, as before, without pause; a defiant challenge to continue, to carry on, rising in power to match the louder, more baleful cry, as if trying even harder to soothe, to lift up, to strengthen.

pose repeats this motion, this action, over and over – allowing the violin to echo its call and response, each one more distinct, more powerful in its tone than the last; wailing louder and louder, responding comfort rising in challenge. After the tenth such reprise, the baleful, echoing cry seems as if cannot be more sad; dying, perhaps even dead…

pose continues, and the response is shockingly different, coming after so many repetitions of the call-and-response: the bow moves quickly, seven times, virtually flashing up and down the strings, producing a sound that seems to be a combination of the mood of the two cries, yet different from each and each other in slight, subtly altering ways; more elegant, more refined. It cracks in places, her lack of complete mastery evident…but she seems completely unfazed by any mistake, moving on, and indeed the cracks make the song itself perhaps even sadder, more real.

pose repeats this new series after a tiny pause; allowing the joined voice to speak again, dominant and powerful, loud and sweeping, ignoring or crashing over any faults with its undeniable strength. This time the series uses eight strokes, bow moving with quick, easy motions as she extends the last passage; a bit slower, flashing only slightly less. There is a feeling of faint transition, as about half of the notes alter just slightly from before as her fingers move rapidly and instinctually on the edge of the instrument, seeming part of the cohesive whole that flows elegantly now, bow tilting faintly to call forth every possible nuance.

pose continues to play, quickly and freely, arm flowing as seamlessly as if she was waving it through air, bow flashing up and down as the sound only continues to grow. The music evoked is a declarative statement spoken in elegant, seamless, slightly twisted notes; there is a raw, imperfect beauty to it, and with fifteen strokes of her arm, it seems to complete its message, as there is the tiniest of pauses…

pose then seems to re-start the new response from the beginning; after a quick burst reminiscent of the whole, she starts actually echoing it with faintly altered, smoothed, elegant notes as the bow flashes up and down repeatedly, restating the combination of sad and defiant, mournful and urging. Seven elegant strokes, then eight, then fifteen…if anything, even more refined than the first time, yet also more varied, as if the notes are emphasizing their elegance. The raw, somewhat unpolished nature is there, but her playing drowns it out in comparison. She finally reaches the last note, and seems to pause, again…

pose finishes this last message at nearly the exact point the song began…and then, very quietly, the violin begins to mourn again, the sound of the first note, slowed so that her arm seems to barely be moving, drawing all the sadness out of the strings, mixing with the echo of the much louder previous passage; its sadness seeming eternal. Eventually, as the bow reaches the bottom, the sound slows…echoes…and fades. At almost the same moment, she exhales again, faintly, and her eyes remain closed as she is as still as a statue, apparently in the thrall of what she has just played.

Heavy-Rotation Selections

With my radio station vamos’ing on the fifth, I thought I’d make a list of Heavy-Rotation (Band I play the most) Albums worth owning.  In alphabetical order.

Alice In Chains – Dirt
Alice In Chains – Jar Of Flies
Nirvana – In Utero
Nirvana – MTV Unplugged In New York
Nirvana – Nevermind
Pearl Jam – Ten
Pearl Jam – Vitalogy
Pearl Jam – Vs.
The Pixies – Bossanova
The Pixies – Surfer Rosa
The Pixies – Trompe Le Monde
The Smashing Pumpkins – Gish
The Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream
Soundgarden – Superunknown
Stone Temple Pilots – Core
Stone Temple Pilots – Purple
Temple Of The Dog – Temple Of The Dog

Sedibluebird – Braveheart, Main Theme & Making Plans/Gathering The Clans (Youtube, 2011)

Short but brilliant rendition on violin.

Two things:
1) My love for the subject matter is probably greater than yours, and
2) She does make one obvious mistake near the beginning

But she tackles a very difficult piece head-on, and as R. Christgau once said, “(s)he did it in one take.”

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWV6dcv21c8

Grade: A-

Bob Seger

Greatest Hits (1994)

Seger gives generic a bad name, even when he’s on and (relatively) good.

How this clumsy oaf ever managed to write “Shame On The Moon” is beyond me.

Oh wait…he didn’t.

Grade: C+

Greatest Hits 2 (2003)

Ahhh…here it is.  Along with the two other best songs he’s ever done.  And a lot of sh1t, including “Katmandu”, quite possibly the most annoying song EVER WRITTEN.
(“Shame On The Moon”, “Fire Lake”)

Grade: C+

Scandal

Scandal (1982)

One decent Smith song, no decent Smyth songs.  But it’s short.

Grade: D

The Warrior (1984)

A poor man’s sellout Heart.  Although they did write the best one themselves. 

Re: the cover – Better than Herman Menderchuk.
(“Beat Of A Heart”)

Grade: C

Robert Plant

Pictures At Eleven (1982)

After listening to this several times, I could finally remember the songs that had the best hooky riffs: “Burning Down One Side” and “Fat Lip”.  But I still had no idea what they were about, nor did I care.

Grade: C-

The Principle Of Moments (1983)

It’s pretty pop atmosphere in contrast to his previous album’s hardish rock hooks.  But Plant isn’t the same without Page, and exactly one song on this album has more than atmospheric charm.
(“In The Mood”)

Grade: C

Shaken ‘N’ Stirred (1985)

The meaningless little ditty is “Little By Little”.  That’s the “good” song.

Grade: D-

Now And Zen (1988)

Nothing worthwhile except the single, which is hooky and hilarious.
(“Tall Cool One”)

Grade: D

Hall & Oates

The Very Best Of Daryl Hall & John Oates (2001)

What exactly were they exceptional at, in any way?

I heard most of these hits when they were fresh, and even then they seemed like second-class pop-by-numbers.  And I was a CHILD.

The fact that I can’t deny the hooks doesn’t mean they add up to much of anything.

Grade: D

Emerson, Lake & Palmer

The Best Of Emerson, Lake & Palmer (1980)

The original version of this (released in 1980) is superior to the 1994 re-release because it ends sooner.

ELP was intricate, eclectic, and popular…like Yes.  But they always struck me as excrutiatingly pretentious when they weren’t being very basically melodic.  And unlike Yes, I never escaped the feeling that they were just bullsh1tting all along.

And, aside from a few basic melodic tunes, they weren’t very interesting.  They should have just given “Still… You Turn Me On” to a band with a real singer and “Lucky Man” to one WITHOUT a synthesizer that threatened to make your eardrums bleed and/or explode when it REALLY kicked in.

Also, they didn’t have Steve Howe.

Grade: D+

Deep Purple

Machine Head (1972)

Forget everything else, including anything calling itself “Greatest” or “Best”.  This is their best, and it contains their only sizeable hit worth owning (“Hush” is a novelty).  It also contains a few other good songs.  “A few” being enough, given that there are only seven songs on the album.
(“Maybe I’m A Leo”, “Space Truckin'”)

Grade: B+

The Cult

Electric (1987)

It’s got some riffs.  It’s also INDESCRIBABLY stupid, making Led Zep I and II look like statements by major philosophers.  And Ian Astbury can’t sing as good as Robert Plant.  Or Robert Palmer.  Or Robert DeNiro.

Grade: D

Sonic Temple (1989)

They put all the good sh1t on the first “side” (see vinyl/cassette) and it’s pretty good in a Metallica-goes-Bob-Rock-Pop-Metal sort of way.  The rest is just dull.  And Ian Astbury has redefined stupid as a lead vocalist/lyricist.  At least David St. Hubbins was funny.  Come to think of it, Astbury’s funny too.  But not in QUITE the same way that we would want.  You don’t laugh at the joke he represents, you laugh at the joke he IS.

Grade: C

Puppy Presents – Good Songs By Otherwise Useless Artists (As They Come To Me)

ABBA – “Dancing Queen” (I CAN’T HELP IT!!!)
Angie Aparo – “Spaceship”
Bananarama – “Cruel Summer”
Ben Folds Five – “Brick”
Berlin – “The Metro”
Big Country – “In A Big Country”
The Buggles – “Video Killed The Radio Star”
The Charlatans – “The Only One I Know” (Great “Hush” ripoff)
Chris Isaak – “Wicked Game”
Misery Signals – “Worlds & Dreams”
Michael Penn – “No Myth”
T. Rex – “Jeepster”
Bob Welch – “Ebony Eyes”

Last Updated/R.I.P. – 3/31/25

Chris Cornell

Euphoria Morning (1999)

This is a radical departure from Soundgarden.  It’s melodic, pretty, mostly soft…recalling, if anything, the slower songs from Cornell’s Andrew Wood tribute, Temple of the Dog.  The lyrics are interesting and the entire thing can be listened to without wincing.

But only occasionally does it rise above pleasant.  The only song that seems to be even intended for airplay is “Can’t Change Me”.  Mostly, it seems like an album full of private ruminations set to mostly spare musical accompaniment.  Artistically not without merit, but I have the feeling that Chris enjoys listening to most of these songs more than pretty much anyone else.
(“Can’t Change Me”, “Mission”)

Grade: C+

The F List – Music

Rick Astley – Whenever You Need Somebody: Keep rollin’, rollin’, rollin’, rollin’…

Jerry Cantrell – Degradation Trip: I am Puppy hear me allow the title to speak for itself.

Green River – Dry As A Bone/Rehab Doll: I didn’t know I.P. Freeley was a musician, too.

Heart – Private Audition: Not fit for public consumption.

Mudhoney – Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge: No fudge for you.

Nonpoint – Development: Arrested.

Orb – Orbus Terrarum: Boop.

Liz Phair – Exile In Guyville: I am Puppy hear me degrade.

The Pixies – Come On Pilgrim: Proof that you CAN, in fact, polish a turd.

Sonic Youth – Daydream Nation: If only they were Sonic Middle-Aged we wouldn’t have to put up with them much longer.

Taproot – Welcome: To your nightmare.

Tool – Opiate: For the Asses.

Type O Negative – World Coming Down: The value of a typical “goth” woman when she takes off her corset.

Yes – Tales From Topographic Oceans: Even BP didn’t pollute water this much.

List Last Updated: 5/13/25

Jerry Cantrell

Boggy Depot (1998)

I can’t think of any reason to listen to it after the first two songs, unless you want an entire album’s worth of proof that his songwriting has descended from brilliant to mostly competent.  “Dickeye” and “Cut You In” are above competent, and could even fit on ‘Alice In Chains’ or maybe even replace the lone low spot on ‘Jar of Flies’.  But that’s not really enough given this man’s talent.
(“Cut You In”)

Grade: C-

Degradation Trip (2002)

Competent.  Professional.  Boring.  Dull.  Meaningless.

Here Jerry calls upon every influence he can think of to try to re-evoke a dead band and fails miserably.  Alice In Chains without Layne Staley is not Alice In Chains, and this is no “dedication”.  If I were to be ultimately optimistic, I’d say it was an abysmal failure to honor a dead friend.  But I’m going to be more realistic, and I’ll say it’s probably Jerry trying to make money off a dead man’s pain.  And I think that stinks.

Grade: F

Local H

As Good As Dead (1996)

Although Scott Lucas can perform an eerily similar vocal to Kurt Cobain, here’s the difference between the two…Kurt Cobain had a brilliant sense of timing, could write killer riffs for more than two or three songs per album, and he understood subtlety.  Cobain expressed more anger on the unplugged “Where Did You Sleep Last Night” than Lucas does on “High-Fiving MF”, by the simple act of SINGING the song and letting the nuances of his voice express his feelings.  Lucas, instead, swears profusely and screams.  Nearly ruins a perfectly good song, too.  Light and Shade, Scott…Light and Shade.
(“Bound For The Floor”, “Eddie Vedder”)

Grade: B-

10/22/12: Lucas UNDERSTANDS it…he just doesn’t always USE it.  And I said “nearly”.

Grade: B

Pack Up The Cats (1998)

Nothing they didn’t do better on ‘As Good As Dead’.  Scott Lucas chilled out a little bit and nearly forgot how to construct a song.
(“All The Kids Are Right”)

Grade: D+

John Mellencamp

The Best That I Could Do 1978-1988 (1997)

Very good selections from six albums.  And by “very good” I’m suggesting that he picked the best that he could of the best that he did.  Not that they were always all that good.  Catchy throughout, more intelligent as they go along.
(“Lonely Ol’ Night”, “Paper In Fire”)

Grade: A-

Michael Jackson

Thriller (1982)

Just because an album is a landmark doesn’t mean you have to like it.  The craft here is undeniable, but I just don’t particularly enjoy listening to some of the hits.  Unlike a lot of today’s pop superstars he did write some of these songs himself, though, and four out of my five favs were Jackson-penned.
(“Wanna Be Startin’ Somethin”, “Beat It”)

Grade: B

Bad (1987)

See Above…change five to four.
(“Smooth Criminal”, “Leave Me Alone”)

Grade: B-

Cyndi Lauper

She’s So Unusual (1983)

Some of it is forgettable, but none of it is truly regrettable.  It’s surprisingly (still) refreshing and, on at least a couple of occasions, the pure pop is transcendent…which for pure pop is very unusual.
You go girl!
(“Girls Just Want To Have Fun”, “She Bop”)

Inspirational Lyric: “I wanna be the one to walk in the Sun.”

Grade: B-

Bryan Adams

Anthology (2005)

Selected to prove that Bryan Adams can write a WHOLE lot of really bad songs.  I mean, this is two and a half HOURS of pure Bryan Adams.  Out of that time, let me sum up the total excitement –
“*Riff Riff*  “Oooo yeah I love this!” “Got my first real six-string…” *Riff Riff* “Ohhh..yeah…that was a cool song…” “Over at the five and dime…” *Riff Riff* “Oh well…wanna make out?”

Grade: D-

Alice Cooper

Alice Cooper’s Greatest Hits (1974)

“I’m Eighteen” and “School’s Out”, believe it or not, were actually considered “hard rock” at the time.   Now they’re considered fun novelty songs.  Controversial, perhaps, then.  Laughable, mostly, now.
Or at least chuckle-able.  But Alice Cooper > Gary Glitter for doing it a few times.
(“Billion Dollar Babies”)

Grade: C

Betty Curse

Here Lies Betty Curse (2006)

Notable as the vehicle for former aspiring actress Megan Burns (’28 Days Later’), who decided she’d much rather direct…errr, I mean front a pop band, so using her 15 minutes she secured a recording contract, bombed and was subsequently dropped.  There’s nothing “goth” about this music, except perhaps its pretension…however, unlike say, Placebo or even (say it ain’t so) Depeche Mode, there’s no guilty/fun pleasure/reward here…it’s Tiffany after a funeral, or an angst-ridden teen’s poetry journal set to dull synth music.  I dub thee, Miss ABBA of Gothville.  Bow down and be forgotten.

Grade: D-

The A List – Music

Led Zeppelin – Led Zeppelin IV: A+
Nirvana – Nevermind: A+
Soundgarden – Superunknown: A+
Pearl Jam – Ten: A+
The Police – Every Breath You Take (The
Classics): A+
Alice In Chains – Jar Of Flies: A+
The Beatles – Abbey Road: A+
Led Zeppelin – Boxed Set: A
Aerosmith – Greatest Hits: A
Nirvana – In Utero: A
The Police – The Police: A
Nirvana – Nirvana: A
Alice In Chains – Dirt: A
The Rolling Stones – Hot Rocks: A
Pink Floyd – A Collection Of Great Dance Songs: A
Nirvana – Icon: Nirvana: A
U2 – The Best Of (1980-1990): A
Nirvana – Unplugged In New York: A
The Doors – Greatest Hits: A
Led Zeppelin – Houses Of The Holy: A
Yes – Fragile: A
Led Zeppelin – Physical Graffiti: A
Pearl Jam – Vs: A
Stone Temple Pilots – Purple: A
Metallica – Ride The Lightning: A
Temple Of The Dog – Temple Of The Dog: A
Various – MTV Buzz Bin, Volume 1: A
Stone Temple Pilots – Core: A
Belly – Star: A
The Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream: A
Fleetwood Mac – Rumours: A
The Rolling Stones – Forty Licks: A
Steely Dan – A Decade Of Steely Dan: A
Ministry – Psalm 69: A
Green Day – International Superhits! : A
Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers – Greatest Hits: A
The Pixies – Bossanova: A
Ministry – The Mind Is A Terrible Thing
To Taste: A
Billy Joel – Greatest Hits Volume 1 & Volume 2: A
Lynyrd Skynyrd – Gold & Platinum: A
Duran Duran – Decade – Greatest Hits: A
Guns N’ Roses – Appetite For Destruction: A
Creedence Clearwater Revival – Chronicle: A-
Pink Floyd – Animals: A-
Metallica – Master Of Puppets: A-
Pink Floyd – Echoes: The Best Of Pink Floyd: A-
Bad Company – 10 From 6: A-
The Beatles – Magical Mystery Tour: A-
The Cars – The Cars: A-
Def Leppard – Hysteria: A-
Pink Floyd – Dark Side Of The Moon: A-
The Who – My Generation: The Very Best
Of The Who: A-
ZZ Top – Greatest Hits: A-
The Pixies – Death To The Pixies: A-
James Horner – Braveheart (Soundtrack): A-
Neil Young – Greatest Hits: A-
The Moody Blues – Greatest Hits/Legend
Of A Band: A-
Nirvana – Live At Reading: A-
Peter Gabriel – The Definitive Two CD Collection
(Hit): A-
Tom Petty – Full Moon Fever: A-
Queen – Greatest Hits: A-
Bruce Springsteen – Born In The U.S.A.: A-
Aerosmith – Toys In The Attic: A-
Pearl Jam – Vitalogy: A-
Type O Negative – Bloody Kisses: A-
The Pixies – Doolittle: A-
Eagles – The Very Best Of The Eagles: A-
The Who – Who’s Next: A-
David Bowie – Changesonebowie: A-
Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here: A-
Limp Bizkit – Significant Other: A-
John Mellencamp – The Best That I Could
Do 1978-1988: A-
Curve – The Frozen EP: A-

Last Updated: 7/7/25

Eagles

The Very Best Of The Eagles (1994)

This band has been accused of being sexist.

For me, their greater offense is being sappy.   After all, plenty of bands over the years have been EXTREMELY sexist in their lyrics and haven’t gotten panned nearly as much.

So it’s much more painful, to me, to have to listen to Don Henley trying to croon “Desperado” than it is to hear the “sexism” of “Lyin’ Eyes”…after all, women DO cheat too.

My preference is to hear them either rock out or perform some good old fashioned pop, with the emphasis on pleasant harmonies rather than whatever-the-hell-they-happen-to-be-saying.  Which they do quite a lot, at their best.  And this IS their best.  Most of it, at least.  Meh.
(“Witchy Woman”, “One Of These Nights”, “Hotel California”)

Grade: A-

Joe Walsh (including ‘James Gang’)

The Best Of Joe Walsh (1978)

Joe Walsh always had a fairly original, signature guitar style.  The problem was writing good songs to showcase that style.  Presented here is most of his best pre-Eagles material, and while you may find his voice annoying (I know I do) and the songs very similar to one another (Not a problem if you like his style, see “AC/DC”), there’s no denying the miracle anthem-by-accident “Life’s Been Good”, never approached/repeated before or since.
(“Funk #49”, “Life’s Been Good”)

Grade: B+

Jenna Greene

Wild Earth Child (2011)

I’ve seen Jenna perform some of these songs live, and both her voice and her demeanor are real (She doesn’t need studio enhancements, and she means every positive, uplifting word). She seems to revel in SHARING her music – hers is not the fake, staged act of a bored professional or a talented fraud trying to pretend they’re happy performing…she IS happy performing, whether it’s to adults listening attentively or little girls dancing about near her. When she says “Thank You” after each song, it comes out as a welcome ray of truth, as if she almost can’t believe that people are clapping for HER, and she doesn’t quite know how to express her profound gratitude that her beautiful music and spirit inspire others as much as they obviously do herself. Husband Doug plays the steady but subtle Mick Fleetwood to Jenna’s often-mystical Stevie Nicks, circa “Gold Dust Woman”, especially on “Samhain Night”.

My favorite songs are the first two, “Affirmation” and “Green Man (Wild Earth Child)”, but I don’t listen to them on repeat or in a mix, I listen to the whole album, because it is truly a REAL experience of carefully crafted, yet spare and simple, Love and Wonder.

This is not “Pagan” music any more than “It’s Love” by King’s X is “Christian” music. They’re both UNIVERSAL music, celebrating the latent spirituality and wonder in ALL of us, no matter how, where, or under what name we choose to express it.

Sowing the seeds of Love, and nurturing them with Faith and Joy. Amen, and Blessed Be.

Grade: B+

7/18/12: Everything above is accurate and true to the best of my knowledge. However, critical integrity must not be tarnished by liner note subjectivity. Hence…

Grade: B-

10/27/12: True Believers are hard to find. A pretty voice and lovely melodies don’t hurt, either.

Grade: B

Era Nocturna

Lackluster (2008)

Pleasantly Gloomy.

Alternating between dark-trance and dark-pop, this will be consistently boring or annoying to anyone that doesn’t like “dark”. To those that DO like “dark”, this will intermittently enthrall/entice and madden/disappoint.

The vocals blend in with the music, or vice versa, rendering them irrelevant on their own, which is fitting for trance and especially goth-inflected trance and the preference of mood and style over substance.

Think of early My Bloody Valentine after a death (or two) in the family and with more of a desire to express ideas and less concentration on fostering (and maintaining) a mood. The synth seems over-used and the drums seem (by contrast) under-used, which is perfect for trance, but when it veers more towards pop it becomes a problem.

Potential? Yes. But for every band that eventually puts out a ‘Loveless’, a masterful work of indecipherable mood music, there are dozens that either never perfected that mood despite repeated attempts or never learned to write consistent hooks (vocal or otherwise) that would make said mood irrelevant.

One of those paths is necessary for any true, long-lasting relevance.
(“If Only I Could”)

Grade: B-

2012: In an attempt to write a proper review, I sought a band to compare them to. The choice was incorrect because, as I state in my initial review, there is more a desire to actually express ideas via intelligible words, to be verbally blunt. My Bloody Valentine they’re not, and they never will be…the wall of sound erected on ‘Loveless’ is, in my opinion, too intricate. But that’s not the point. The specialty of THIS band is writing catchy songs with mostly vocal/synth hooks (the vocal ones are actually better than the synth ones, not to insult the synth ones) and an increasing incorporation of drums. All that being said, I still think this is exactly what I graded it initially…pretty good. If the writing ever consistently reaches the level of “If Only I Could” and “Beautiful Death” (The playing is already there), then they will have something…no ‘Loveless’, but Dae Noctem doesn’t want that, I think…she wants to express herself in a blatantly hooky way. And sometimes, she succeeds.

Grade: B-

5/5/25: Corrected release date.

The Middle East Downstairs – 10/9/2010

I went to The Middle East nightclub on Saturday and saw two bands…here are Christgau type reviews of both…anyone involved with the first one, please feel free to comment or post info on your band and/or where to buy your cd.

Band One: Quite surprising, really.  So many things to like.  The only problem, really, seems to be songwriting.  But then, Nirvana’s first CD wasn’t exactly Nirvana…they tend to wander a bit, like the Dead on a bad night.  There aren’t enough hooks…whether this is intentional or not I’m unsure, but it would be wise to note that noone would have cared what Cobain had to say if he hadn’t surrounded  his lyrics with hardcore riffs. 
That being said…it was a truly inspired performance.  The instrumentation was superb, especially the lead guitarist, who brings to mind good Catherine Wheel, and the drummer, who brings to mind David Grohl.  Melodic, powerful, grand, epic, beautiful, mournful, unmistakably positive and without a doubt “real”…I think they’re on to something here.  They love it, even if I don’t…and eventually, I just might.

Grade: B+

Band Two: No surprise.  MUCH, MUCH hookier.  Much more predictable.  Much more repetitive.  Much less point.

Grade: D+

Placebo

Once More With Feeling (2004)

Their songs have the same sameness as Depeche Mode and New Order.  Fortunately, unlike New Order they aren’t boring as hell, and unlike Depeche Mode they mean it and aren’t pretentious as hell. And the lead singer is dead sexy.
(“Pure Morning”, “Where Is My Mind?”)

Grade: B+

2012: “I am not gay, although I wish I were, just to piss off homophobes.” -Kurt Cobain

Grade: B